Why Choose Us
See How We Compare to the Competition
![]() |
Cash 4 Gold | GoldFellow | MyGoldEnvelope | |
| Competitive price matching | 200% | 110% | Doubles difference between offers |
|
| Better Business Bureau Accredited |
||||
| Free insurance | $2,500 | $100 | $1,000 | $500 |
| Days to reject a check offer |
30 days | 12 days | 10 days | 10 days |
| Days to return a non-check offer |
30 days | Non-returnable | 1 day | N/A |
| Fee for direct deposit |
$0 | $4.99 | $10 | N/A |
| Security packaging (for privacy, physical and tear-proof protection) |
||||
| Instantly print a shipping label |
||||
| Listed on New York Stock Exchange | ||||
| Funding Options | ||||
| PayPal™ | ||||
| Direct deposit into your bank account |
||||
| Paper check | ||||
Gold Promise Beats the Competition
Competitive Price Matching
We're so confident in our pricing that we offer a 200% Best Price Promise.† If you find a better written offer from an online competitor, we'll double it! Learn more.
Better Business Bureau® Accredited
Because Gold Promise is a BBB Accredited business, you can be confident that you're getting a fair price and exceptional service. We are contractually obligated to uphold the BBB’s Standards for Trust® and agree to resolve any complaints that may be filed against us with the BBB.
Free Shipping + up to $2,500 Free Insurance‡
Whether you ship your gold using our GP InsureTrack Envelope™ or prepaid shipping label, we'll insure it up to $2,500 at no cost. Even if you decide not to accept our payment, we'll return your gold free of charge and insured. Want more insurance? Just ask. Learn more.
More Time to Decide — 30-Day Return Promise
No matter which funding option you choose, you'll get 30 days to decide if you want to keep or reject the payment. Learn more.
Security Packaging
We have designed our kit to provide secure protection and privacy for your gold and jewelry. Your jewelry is placed inside the GP GoldProtector™, which is made out of reinforced carton substrate that protects your jewelry during shipment and prevents strangers from feeling the contents through the envelope. The GP GoldProtector™ is shipped back to Gold Promise in the GP InsureTrack Envelope™ (made from Tyvek®), which makes the return package virtually indestructible to further protect the shipment.
Instantly Print a Prepaid Shipping Label
No need to wait for a GP FastPack™! You can print a prepaid shipping label now and send in your gold right away.
Experience and Affiliations
Feel confident using Gold Promise. We've got experience and the affiliations to back it up. Gold Promise is operated by a subsidiary of Cash America International, Inc., a publicly traded company on the New York Stock Exchange (CSH). The Cash America International, Inc. family of companies has over 25 years of experience in the gold buying industry. We are also registered with the Jewelers Vigilance Committee and the Jewelers Board of Trade, which means we have promised to uphold the ethics and integrity of the jewelry industry through our own business practices. Learn more.
Fast and Free Funding Options
Account — We'll deposit payment into your PayPal™ account within 24 hours of processing your gold.§
Direct Deposit — We'll deposit funds into your bank account within 24 hours of processing your gold.§
Paper Check — We'll mail you a paper check within 24 hours of processing your gold.§
Remember, any payment option you choose is free of any charges.
Tracking Every Step of the Way
We offer comprehensive online tracking, so you know where your jewelry is at all times. You'll even be able to track your gold's return trip to you if you decide not to accept payment.
Learn more about Gold Promise.

